Traci Sarnataro - Testimonials

Tell Us Your Story

5/18/2022 - Leanne M Bought a Single Family home in 2022 in East northport, NY.

5 STAR Local knowledge 5 STAR Process expertise 5 STAR Responsiveness 5 STAR Negotiation skills Traci helped us find and close on our dream home in this tough market. She was knowledgeable, extremely responsive and quick to act. We’re not originally from the area, so her guidance was really valuable. Since we were buying new construction, the entire process from the time we made an offer to final closing, took over a year, and she was there at every step of the way. She not only made the process seamless, but enjoyable as well.

Leanne M

"We couldn't have asked for a better Relator when it came to selling our childhood home.

Traci was extremely knowledgeable about the local market and made the whole process feel effortless. She guided us through each step, making sure we understood everything. We can’t thank her enough! We truly were in the best hands.!"

ltfreud

Traci Sarnataro acted as my real estate broker, as I recently closed on my dream house in East Rockaway, New York.

Her guidance and knowledge in the field are unsurpassed. She helped my husband, pets, and I find a beautiful mint condition house. With her unconditional patience with a million questions; she was patient, wise, and practical at every turn of the process. She lessened my fears and hesitations with calm fortitude. Her legal background in the field also adds to her ability to steer clients through the twists and turns in purchasing a home. Traci helped the process move seamlessly; as she kept me abreast of any and all concerns along the way. I would never turn to another broker whether buying or selling and have already begun referring her to interested homebuyers and sellers. Happy Home Owner Daryel Groom

Daryel Groom

Sold a Single Family home in 2020 in Amityville, NY.

5 STAR Local knowledge 5 STAR Process expertise 5 STAR Responsiveness 5 STAR Negotiation skills Traci was a pleasure to work with. She obviously enjoys what she does. Traci is always available and accurate with tasks. During Covid, she was prepared with hand gloves and sanitizer. She guided us with ease through the selling of our home.

Ellen Reilly

Bought a Single Family home in 2014 in Northport, NY.

5 STAR Local knowledge 5 STAR Process expertise 5 STAR Responsiveness 5 STAR Negotiation skills Traci Sarnataro is an amazing agent. She is very detail oriented, flexible with time and loves what she does. She found us an amazing house at an amazing price. Highly recommend to anyone looking to buy, sell or rent!

Krystle Schultz

5 STAR Local knowledge 5 STAR Process expertise 5 STAR Responsiveness 5 STAR Negotiation skills In this market where inventory is extremely limited, we would not have been able to purchase our first home without Traci!

Not only did she coordinate and attend several showings with us, she was always available to answer questions and provide guidance as we navigated making offers, negotiating, and (finally!) closing on our first home. She is responsive, always on time, positive and advocated for us along the way. We loved getting to know Traci throughout the process and highly recommend working with her!

K Holden

7/21/2025 - vincentrice233 Bought a home in 2025.

5 STAR Local knowledge 5 STAR Process expertise 5 STAR Responsiveness 5 STAR Negotiation skills Traci was incredibly helpful throughout the whole home buying process. She has such great knowledge and really helped us on our journey to find our home. She always responds quickly, and answers any questions we had to make it very easy to understand. She was truly the best and I couldn’t recommend her more.

Vincent Rice
Reviews on Zillow
Average Rating
"Traci is a one-of-a-kind real-estate professional. Coming from a metropolitan area, I have worked with many real-estate professionals in the past. Traci was by far the most honest, responsive, and realistic. My husband and I truly felt she had our best interest at hand. She shared her expert point of view on what were a realistic yet competitive offers, and never pushed us to a place where we felt uncomfortable. She was responsive, always available, and overall a kind person - the best to work with on such an important decision. I highly recommend Traci for anyone looking to buy a home on Long Island."
5 /5.0
by Nicole Shevlin
"Traci was SUCH a big help in finding a rental on Long Island!! She was quick to respond and found us the most wonderful (and reasonably priced) property, much better than we could have ever found ourselves. As a brand-new renter, she was great at explaining how the process worked as well!"
5 /5.0
by Lexi Szyndler
"Traci was incredibly helpful throughout the whole home buying process. She has such great knowledge and really helped us on our journey to find our home. She always responds quickly, and answers any questions we had to make it very easy to understand. She was truly the best and I couldn’t recommend her more."
5 /5.0
by vincentrice233
"Traci helped us find and close on our dream home in this tough market. She was knowledgeable, extremely responsive and quick to act. We’re not originally from the area, so her guidance was really valuable.Since we were buying new construction, the entire process from the time we made an offer to final closing, took over a year, and she was there at every step of the way.She not only made the process seamless, but enjoyable as well."
5 /5.0
by Leanne M
"In this market where inventory is extremely limited, we would not have been able to purchase our first home without Traci! Not only did she coordinate and attend several showings with us, she was always available to answer questions and provide guidance as we navigated making offers, negotiating, and (finally!) closing on our first home. She is responsive, always on time, positive and advocated for us along the way. We loved getting to know Traci throughout the process and highly recommend working with her!"
5 /5.0
by kholden1203
"Traci was a pleasure to work with. She obviously enjoys what she does. Traci is always available and accurate with tasks. During Covid, she was prepared with hand gloves and sanitizer. She guided us with ease through the selling of our home."
5 /5.0
by emhreilly
"We had the pleasure of working with Traci for several years, and she was incredible throughout the entire process. As very picky homebuyers, we took our time. Traci was always patient, supportive, and never once pressured us to make a decision.What we appreciated the most was Traci's honesty. She consistently pointed out both the good and the bad in each home, which made us trust her completely. We are very grateful for her dedication and would highly recommend Traci to anyone looking for a reliable and trustworthy realtor. Traci knows her stuff, educates her clients and will help you find your dream home - we couldn't be happier!!!! Thank you, Traci."
5 /5.0
by ThomasGeneva0
"We couldn't have asked for a better Relator when it came to selling our childhood home. Traci was extremely knowledgeable about the local market and made the whole process feel effortless. She guided us through each step, making sure we understood everything. We can’t thank her enough! We truly were in the best hands.!"
5 /5.0
by ltfreud
"We have worked with Traci on 3 transactions, a purchase, a sale and a rental. Throughout each process, Traci was a superstar. She was always available and happy to guide us and answer all our questions. She successfully negotiated on our behalf and we are extremely satisfied customers! I think her background as a real estate attorney helped in that regard. We have recommended Traci to our friends and family members and they loved her as well."
5 /5.0
by nbrodgers
"Oh my... where do I even begin?As first-time homebuyers, the process was incredibly intimidating. We saw several houses and met a few realtors along the way, but many felt rushed or pushy. Then we walked into an open house and met Traci and Laura. They were warm, kind, genuine, and welcoming—never pushy. They just had the most amazing aura about them. As soon as I left, I turned to my husband and said, "We just met our realtors."Choosing Traci and Laura was hands down one of the best decisions we made. Everything they say about themselves is absolutely true—they are honest, kind, caring, and truly have their clients' best interests at heart.From the very beginning of our home search to closing day, Traci and Laura guided us every step of the way. They always gave us options, offered honest feedback, answered every question, and made sure we felt comfortable and informed throughout the entire process. We never once felt pressured—only supported.The best way I can describe the experience is that it felt like house hunting with your best girlfriends. They made what could have been a stressful experience so enjoyable. Honestly, I almost wish we were buying another house just so we could spend more time with them!Not only did we end up with a beautiful home and a great deal, but we also walked away with two wonderful friends.We've already been telling all of our friends that when they're ready to move to Long Island, they need to call Traci and Laura.Traci and Laura, you are simply the best. Words truly aren't enough to express how special you both are or how grateful we are for everything you did for us. Thank you for making our first home-buying experience one we'll always cherish."
5 /5.0
by Farhana Azad
Zillow Logo

Property Search

Fair Housing Icon NY Fair Housing Notice